Does duplicating a spell with Wish count as casting that spell? The 2019 Stack Overflow Developer Survey Results Are InWhen using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?If the Wish spell is used to duplicate the effect of Simulacrum, are existing duplicates destroyed?If the Wish spell duplicates an Abjuration spell, does it charge the Arcane Ward?Does the wish spell trigger the 33% automatically?Is a permanent teleportation circle only a destination, and not a point of departure?Does using Wish for a use that's mentioned elsewhere, but that's not duplicating a spell, cause stress?Does a cantrip count as a spell for the purpose of Wish's penalties?Could a wish spell make someone who is not able to cast the wish spell, able again?When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?Does Silence cancel a readied spell?Does casting Call Lightning under an existing storm extend its effective range?Can a creature travel from the destination of the Teleportation Circle spell back to the source circle?If the Wish spell duplicates an Abjuration spell, does it charge the Arcane Ward?

Is this food a bread or a loaf?

How was Skylab's orbit inclination chosen?

Manuscript was "unsubmitted" because the manuscript was deposited in Arxiv Preprints

Can distinct morphisms between curves induce the same morphism on singular cohomology?

Does duplicating a spell with Wish count as casting that spell?

Why could you hear an Amstrad CPC working?

Why don't Unix/Linux systems traverse through directories until they find the required version of a linked library?

Deadlock Graph and Interpretation, solution to avoid

"Riffle" two strings

Does it makes sense to buy a new cycle to learn riding?

JSON.serialize: is it possible to suppress null values of a map?

What is the use of option -o in the useradd command?

Is flight data recorder erased after every flight?

"To split hairs" vs "To be pedantic"

I looked up a future colleague on LinkedIn before I started a job. I told my colleague about it and he seemed surprised. Should I apologize?

Landlord wants to switch my lease to a "Land contract" to "get back at the city"

Realistic Alternatives to Dust: What Else Could Feed a Plankton Bloom?

Confusion about non-derivable continuous functions

How to make payment on the internet without leaving a money trail?

Is three citations per paragraph excessive for undergraduate research paper?

How can I fix this gap between bookcases I made?

How to deal with fear of taking dependencies

What is the steepest angle that a canal can be traversable without locks?

How can I create a character who can assume the widest possible range of creature sizes?



Does duplicating a spell with Wish count as casting that spell?



The 2019 Stack Overflow Developer Survey Results Are InWhen using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?If the Wish spell is used to duplicate the effect of Simulacrum, are existing duplicates destroyed?If the Wish spell duplicates an Abjuration spell, does it charge the Arcane Ward?Does the wish spell trigger the 33% automatically?Is a permanent teleportation circle only a destination, and not a point of departure?Does using Wish for a use that's mentioned elsewhere, but that's not duplicating a spell, cause stress?Does a cantrip count as a spell for the purpose of Wish's penalties?Could a wish spell make someone who is not able to cast the wish spell, able again?When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?Does Silence cancel a readied spell?Does casting Call Lightning under an existing storm extend its effective range?Can a creature travel from the destination of the Teleportation Circle spell back to the source circle?If the Wish spell duplicates an Abjuration spell, does it charge the Arcane Ward?



.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;








12












$begingroup$


Premise



This question was inspired by the line of reasoning in this answer. There are a number of spells that have wording "when you cast" or "as you cast" included. Specifically, some effects have predicates like "when you cast" in order to come into effect. If wish does not count as casting the a duplicated spell, it could have ramifications of the resulting effects.



Examples



Call lightning requires choosing a location




When you cast the spell, choose a point you can see under the cloud. A bolt of lightning flashes down from the cloud to that point. Each creature within 5 feet of that point...




Teleportation circle requires drawing a circle as you cast the spell for the portal to show up in.




As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...




Does a wizard duplicating a spell with wish count as casting the duplicated spell?










share|improve this question











$endgroup$







  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related: When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?
    $endgroup$
    – Rubiksmoose
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    ...and the difference between "cast the spell" and "cast this spell" is also potentially interesting.
    $endgroup$
    – Ben Barden
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related, but not Duplicate: What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?
    $endgroup$
    – Xirema
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    A "fun" follow-on question to confuse the issue even further: what level Counterspell/Dispel magic is required to guarantee countering/dispelling a Wish duplicating an 8th-level spell?
    $endgroup$
    – Ryan Thompson
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    @RyanThompson I'd argue that because Counterspell interrupts the "process of casting", and Wish removes any casting time for the duplicated spell, that you would have to counter the Wish itself (i.e. at 9th level).
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago

















12












$begingroup$


Premise



This question was inspired by the line of reasoning in this answer. There are a number of spells that have wording "when you cast" or "as you cast" included. Specifically, some effects have predicates like "when you cast" in order to come into effect. If wish does not count as casting the a duplicated spell, it could have ramifications of the resulting effects.



Examples



Call lightning requires choosing a location




When you cast the spell, choose a point you can see under the cloud. A bolt of lightning flashes down from the cloud to that point. Each creature within 5 feet of that point...




Teleportation circle requires drawing a circle as you cast the spell for the portal to show up in.




As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...




Does a wizard duplicating a spell with wish count as casting the duplicated spell?










share|improve this question











$endgroup$







  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related: When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?
    $endgroup$
    – Rubiksmoose
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    ...and the difference between "cast the spell" and "cast this spell" is also potentially interesting.
    $endgroup$
    – Ben Barden
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related, but not Duplicate: What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?
    $endgroup$
    – Xirema
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    A "fun" follow-on question to confuse the issue even further: what level Counterspell/Dispel magic is required to guarantee countering/dispelling a Wish duplicating an 8th-level spell?
    $endgroup$
    – Ryan Thompson
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    @RyanThompson I'd argue that because Counterspell interrupts the "process of casting", and Wish removes any casting time for the duplicated spell, that you would have to counter the Wish itself (i.e. at 9th level).
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago













12












12








12


1



$begingroup$


Premise



This question was inspired by the line of reasoning in this answer. There are a number of spells that have wording "when you cast" or "as you cast" included. Specifically, some effects have predicates like "when you cast" in order to come into effect. If wish does not count as casting the a duplicated spell, it could have ramifications of the resulting effects.



Examples



Call lightning requires choosing a location




When you cast the spell, choose a point you can see under the cloud. A bolt of lightning flashes down from the cloud to that point. Each creature within 5 feet of that point...




Teleportation circle requires drawing a circle as you cast the spell for the portal to show up in.




As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...




Does a wizard duplicating a spell with wish count as casting the duplicated spell?










share|improve this question











$endgroup$




Premise



This question was inspired by the line of reasoning in this answer. There are a number of spells that have wording "when you cast" or "as you cast" included. Specifically, some effects have predicates like "when you cast" in order to come into effect. If wish does not count as casting the a duplicated spell, it could have ramifications of the resulting effects.



Examples



Call lightning requires choosing a location




When you cast the spell, choose a point you can see under the cloud. A bolt of lightning flashes down from the cloud to that point. Each creature within 5 feet of that point...




Teleportation circle requires drawing a circle as you cast the spell for the portal to show up in.




As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...




Does a wizard duplicating a spell with wish count as casting the duplicated spell?







dnd-5e spells wish






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 2 hours ago









V2Blast

26.3k591161




26.3k591161










asked 6 hours ago









GcLGcL

12.8k13883




12.8k13883







  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related: When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?
    $endgroup$
    – Rubiksmoose
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    ...and the difference between "cast the spell" and "cast this spell" is also potentially interesting.
    $endgroup$
    – Ben Barden
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related, but not Duplicate: What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?
    $endgroup$
    – Xirema
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    A "fun" follow-on question to confuse the issue even further: what level Counterspell/Dispel magic is required to guarantee countering/dispelling a Wish duplicating an 8th-level spell?
    $endgroup$
    – Ryan Thompson
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    @RyanThompson I'd argue that because Counterspell interrupts the "process of casting", and Wish removes any casting time for the duplicated spell, that you would have to counter the Wish itself (i.e. at 9th level).
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago












  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related: When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?
    $endgroup$
    – Rubiksmoose
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    ...and the difference between "cast the spell" and "cast this spell" is also potentially interesting.
    $endgroup$
    – Ben Barden
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Related, but not Duplicate: What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?
    $endgroup$
    – Xirema
    5 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    A "fun" follow-on question to confuse the issue even further: what level Counterspell/Dispel magic is required to guarantee countering/dispelling a Wish duplicating an 8th-level spell?
    $endgroup$
    – Ryan Thompson
    5 hours ago











  • $begingroup$
    @RyanThompson I'd argue that because Counterspell interrupts the "process of casting", and Wish removes any casting time for the duplicated spell, that you would have to counter the Wish itself (i.e. at 9th level).
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago







1




1




$begingroup$
Related: When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?
$endgroup$
– Rubiksmoose
5 hours ago





$begingroup$
Related: When using wish to replicate a spell, what school of magic does it count as?
$endgroup$
– Rubiksmoose
5 hours ago













$begingroup$
...and the difference between "cast the spell" and "cast this spell" is also potentially interesting.
$endgroup$
– Ben Barden
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
...and the difference between "cast the spell" and "cast this spell" is also potentially interesting.
$endgroup$
– Ben Barden
5 hours ago




1




1




$begingroup$
Related, but not Duplicate: What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?
$endgroup$
– Xirema
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
Related, but not Duplicate: What exactly is ignored in the “requirements” of a spell when Wishing for it?
$endgroup$
– Xirema
5 hours ago




1




1




$begingroup$
A "fun" follow-on question to confuse the issue even further: what level Counterspell/Dispel magic is required to guarantee countering/dispelling a Wish duplicating an 8th-level spell?
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
5 hours ago





$begingroup$
A "fun" follow-on question to confuse the issue even further: what level Counterspell/Dispel magic is required to guarantee countering/dispelling a Wish duplicating an 8th-level spell?
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
5 hours ago













$begingroup$
@RyanThompson I'd argue that because Counterspell interrupts the "process of casting", and Wish removes any casting time for the duplicated spell, that you would have to counter the Wish itself (i.e. at 9th level).
$endgroup$
– Abe Karplus
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
@RyanThompson I'd argue that because Counterspell interrupts the "process of casting", and Wish removes any casting time for the duplicated spell, that you would have to counter the Wish itself (i.e. at 9th level).
$endgroup$
– Abe Karplus
5 hours ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















10












$begingroup$

Yes, it does.



This is never explicitly stated, but we can infer it from the Sage Advice Compendium which notes that the sorcerer's Twinned Spell feature works on spells duplicated by wish:




Can my sorcerer use Twinned Spell on a spell duplicated by the casting of a wish spell? And if so, how many sorcery points does it cost? Yes, you can. It costs the number of sorcery points appropriate for the level of the spell you’re duplicating




The Twinned Spell metamagic option reads:




When you cast a spell that targets only one creature and doesn't have
a range of self, you can spend a number of sorcery points equal to the
spell's level to target a second creature in range with the same spell
(1 sorcery point if the spell is a cantrip).




The wish spell has a range of self, so Twinned Spell must be applying to the casting of the duplicated spell.



Also, just as a matter of common sense, there's no reason wish would be able to duplicate all but a rather arbitrary subset of spells.






share|improve this answer










New contributor




Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    Is twinned spell casting two spells or just adding a target?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Twinned Spell is explicitly just adding a target, but it's adding it to a spell that has been cast, namely, the one being replicated by Wish.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I'm having trouble parsing this comment. You're twinning the spell duplicated by wish to illustrate a point?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Yes. We want to know whether the spell duplicated by Wish has been cast. Twinned Spell only applies to spells that have been cast. Twinned Spell does apply, according to Sage Advice. Therefore, the duplicated spell has been cast.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    excellent. Now I follow.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago


















6












$begingroup$

A lot of weird things happen if a Duplicated Spell is not 'Cast'



In this post, I am not necessarily going to be making an argument as to whether a spell cast by Wish counts as being 'Cast' or not (well, maybe at the end...). I am, however, going to make arguments about what the consequences would be if using Wish to duplicate a spell means the spell in question has not been 'Cast'.



All of the following sections involve considerations that become true if a spell duplicated by Wish is not, mechanically, 'Casted'.



"When this spell is cast again..."



As mentioned in the linked question about Simulacrum, any spell that has a clause reading something like "if this spell is cast again..." would not have that clause take place. Simulacrums will stick around, you can summon multiple Spiritual Weapons, and so on.



"If you cast this spell with a higher spell slot..."



Any spell duplicated by Wish would be cast at its lowest level, and receive no benefits from being up-cast at a higher level of spell slot.



"As part of the action used to cast this spell..."



If the spell says that something does happens "as part of the casting of the spell", then that something doesn't happen.



This means that spells like Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade have no effect: they both stipulate that something occurs during the casting of the spell:




As part of the action used to cast this spell, you must make a melee attack with a weapon against one creature within the spell's range, otherwise the spell fails. [...]



Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade, Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide, pg. 142 & 143




This also affects spells like Teleportation Circle ("As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...") or Magic Circle ("When you cast this spell, you can elect to cause its magic to operate in the reverse direction...").



Esoteric: can a spell's casting be "wasted" if it was never cast?




You and up to eight willing creatures within range project your astral bodies into the Astral Plane (the spell fails and the casting is wasted if you are already on that plane).



Astral Projection, Player's Handbook, pg. 215




This is where the RAW becomes unclear: what happens if a spell fails without having been 'Cast'? What does "the casting is wasted" mean for a spell that wasn't cast?



"The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine..."




The effects of different spells add together while the durations of those spells overlap. The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine, however. Instead, the most potent effect—such as the highest bonus—from those castings applies while their durations overlap, or the most recent effect applies if the castings are equally potent and their durations overlap.



Combining Magical Effects, Player's Handbook, pg. 205




If the second spell produced by Wish was not 'Cast' into being, then this rule would not apply. After all, the rule specifically says that the spell has to be 'Cast' multiple times, and this would be the case from nearly any other source, including an Innate Spellcaster, but not from spells duplicated by Wish.



You can't Target yourself with an AOE spell




If a spell targets a creature of your choice, you can choose yourself, unless the creature must be hostile or specifically a creature other than you. If you are in the area of effect of a spell you cast, you can target yourself.



Targeting yourself, Player's Handbook, pg. 204




So if you're duplicating a spell that normally allows you to choose targets in an area of effect, you'd no longer be able to target yourself.




Let's try another angle...



From all that I've listed above, it's clear that the mechanical consequences of spells duplicated by Wish, if they don't count as being 'Cast', are quite significant. But the rules being weird is not sufficient proof that they're wrong or misinterpreted.



What does the chapter's opening paragraph say about Spellcasting?




Spellcasting



Magic permeates the worlds of D&D and most often appears in the form of a spell.



This chapter provides the rules for casting spells. Different character classes have distinctive ways of learning and preparing their spells, and monsters use spells in unique ways. Regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here.



Spellcasting, Player's Handbook, pg. 201




So here's an interesting passage: in the same paragraph, the book says both "this chapter provides the rules for casting spells", but also says "regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here".



There's [at least] two ways to interpret that.



One way is to say that that last sentence is an exception to the former: the chapter contains rules for casting spells, but spells produced by "some other means" still also obey those rules.



The other way is to say that the last sentence is implying that any spell produced by any source is obeying the same rules here because, implicitly, a spell produced by any other means has been 'Cast'.



So in one way, it might come down to how you interpret this paragraph. Under the latter interpretation, then yes, a spell duplicated by Wish was 'Cast'. There wouldn't be any way to resolve its effects otherwise.



Under the former interpretation... Well, unless someone finds the smoking gun I missed, then it comes down to what your DM says.






share|improve this answer











$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    If feasible, please put a tl;dr summation at the top of the post.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    3 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I think the argument is whether Wish duplicating a spell effect counts as casting the duplicated spell or counts as casting a Wish spell. How many sorcery points to quicken a Wish spell duplicating another spell? 9 or less than 9?
    $endgroup$
    – Quigath
    2 hours ago












Your Answer





StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function ()
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix)
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
);
);
, "mathjax-editing");

StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "122"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);

else
createEditor();

);

function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);



);













draft saved

draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f144884%2fdoes-duplicating-a-spell-with-wish-count-as-casting-that-spell%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes








2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









10












$begingroup$

Yes, it does.



This is never explicitly stated, but we can infer it from the Sage Advice Compendium which notes that the sorcerer's Twinned Spell feature works on spells duplicated by wish:




Can my sorcerer use Twinned Spell on a spell duplicated by the casting of a wish spell? And if so, how many sorcery points does it cost? Yes, you can. It costs the number of sorcery points appropriate for the level of the spell you’re duplicating




The Twinned Spell metamagic option reads:




When you cast a spell that targets only one creature and doesn't have
a range of self, you can spend a number of sorcery points equal to the
spell's level to target a second creature in range with the same spell
(1 sorcery point if the spell is a cantrip).




The wish spell has a range of self, so Twinned Spell must be applying to the casting of the duplicated spell.



Also, just as a matter of common sense, there's no reason wish would be able to duplicate all but a rather arbitrary subset of spells.






share|improve this answer










New contributor




Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    Is twinned spell casting two spells or just adding a target?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Twinned Spell is explicitly just adding a target, but it's adding it to a spell that has been cast, namely, the one being replicated by Wish.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I'm having trouble parsing this comment. You're twinning the spell duplicated by wish to illustrate a point?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Yes. We want to know whether the spell duplicated by Wish has been cast. Twinned Spell only applies to spells that have been cast. Twinned Spell does apply, according to Sage Advice. Therefore, the duplicated spell has been cast.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    excellent. Now I follow.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago















10












$begingroup$

Yes, it does.



This is never explicitly stated, but we can infer it from the Sage Advice Compendium which notes that the sorcerer's Twinned Spell feature works on spells duplicated by wish:




Can my sorcerer use Twinned Spell on a spell duplicated by the casting of a wish spell? And if so, how many sorcery points does it cost? Yes, you can. It costs the number of sorcery points appropriate for the level of the spell you’re duplicating




The Twinned Spell metamagic option reads:




When you cast a spell that targets only one creature and doesn't have
a range of self, you can spend a number of sorcery points equal to the
spell's level to target a second creature in range with the same spell
(1 sorcery point if the spell is a cantrip).




The wish spell has a range of self, so Twinned Spell must be applying to the casting of the duplicated spell.



Also, just as a matter of common sense, there's no reason wish would be able to duplicate all but a rather arbitrary subset of spells.






share|improve this answer










New contributor




Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    Is twinned spell casting two spells or just adding a target?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Twinned Spell is explicitly just adding a target, but it's adding it to a spell that has been cast, namely, the one being replicated by Wish.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I'm having trouble parsing this comment. You're twinning the spell duplicated by wish to illustrate a point?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Yes. We want to know whether the spell duplicated by Wish has been cast. Twinned Spell only applies to spells that have been cast. Twinned Spell does apply, according to Sage Advice. Therefore, the duplicated spell has been cast.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    excellent. Now I follow.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago













10












10








10





$begingroup$

Yes, it does.



This is never explicitly stated, but we can infer it from the Sage Advice Compendium which notes that the sorcerer's Twinned Spell feature works on spells duplicated by wish:




Can my sorcerer use Twinned Spell on a spell duplicated by the casting of a wish spell? And if so, how many sorcery points does it cost? Yes, you can. It costs the number of sorcery points appropriate for the level of the spell you’re duplicating




The Twinned Spell metamagic option reads:




When you cast a spell that targets only one creature and doesn't have
a range of self, you can spend a number of sorcery points equal to the
spell's level to target a second creature in range with the same spell
(1 sorcery point if the spell is a cantrip).




The wish spell has a range of self, so Twinned Spell must be applying to the casting of the duplicated spell.



Also, just as a matter of common sense, there's no reason wish would be able to duplicate all but a rather arbitrary subset of spells.






share|improve this answer










New contributor




Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






$endgroup$



Yes, it does.



This is never explicitly stated, but we can infer it from the Sage Advice Compendium which notes that the sorcerer's Twinned Spell feature works on spells duplicated by wish:




Can my sorcerer use Twinned Spell on a spell duplicated by the casting of a wish spell? And if so, how many sorcery points does it cost? Yes, you can. It costs the number of sorcery points appropriate for the level of the spell you’re duplicating




The Twinned Spell metamagic option reads:




When you cast a spell that targets only one creature and doesn't have
a range of self, you can spend a number of sorcery points equal to the
spell's level to target a second creature in range with the same spell
(1 sorcery point if the spell is a cantrip).




The wish spell has a range of self, so Twinned Spell must be applying to the casting of the duplicated spell.



Also, just as a matter of common sense, there's no reason wish would be able to duplicate all but a rather arbitrary subset of spells.







share|improve this answer










New contributor




Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited 2 hours ago









V2Blast

26.3k591161




26.3k591161






New contributor




Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









answered 5 hours ago









Abe KarplusAbe Karplus

20124




20124




New contributor




Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.





New contributor





Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






Abe Karplus is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.











  • $begingroup$
    Is twinned spell casting two spells or just adding a target?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Twinned Spell is explicitly just adding a target, but it's adding it to a spell that has been cast, namely, the one being replicated by Wish.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I'm having trouble parsing this comment. You're twinning the spell duplicated by wish to illustrate a point?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Yes. We want to know whether the spell duplicated by Wish has been cast. Twinned Spell only applies to spells that have been cast. Twinned Spell does apply, according to Sage Advice. Therefore, the duplicated spell has been cast.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    excellent. Now I follow.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago
















  • $begingroup$
    Is twinned spell casting two spells or just adding a target?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Twinned Spell is explicitly just adding a target, but it's adding it to a spell that has been cast, namely, the one being replicated by Wish.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I'm having trouble parsing this comment. You're twinning the spell duplicated by wish to illustrate a point?
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    @GcL Yes. We want to know whether the spell duplicated by Wish has been cast. Twinned Spell only applies to spells that have been cast. Twinned Spell does apply, according to Sage Advice. Therefore, the duplicated spell has been cast.
    $endgroup$
    – Abe Karplus
    5 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    excellent. Now I follow.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    5 hours ago















$begingroup$
Is twinned spell casting two spells or just adding a target?
$endgroup$
– GcL
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
Is twinned spell casting two spells or just adding a target?
$endgroup$
– GcL
5 hours ago












$begingroup$
@GcL Twinned Spell is explicitly just adding a target, but it's adding it to a spell that has been cast, namely, the one being replicated by Wish.
$endgroup$
– Abe Karplus
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
@GcL Twinned Spell is explicitly just adding a target, but it's adding it to a spell that has been cast, namely, the one being replicated by Wish.
$endgroup$
– Abe Karplus
5 hours ago












$begingroup$
I'm having trouble parsing this comment. You're twinning the spell duplicated by wish to illustrate a point?
$endgroup$
– GcL
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
I'm having trouble parsing this comment. You're twinning the spell duplicated by wish to illustrate a point?
$endgroup$
– GcL
5 hours ago












$begingroup$
@GcL Yes. We want to know whether the spell duplicated by Wish has been cast. Twinned Spell only applies to spells that have been cast. Twinned Spell does apply, according to Sage Advice. Therefore, the duplicated spell has been cast.
$endgroup$
– Abe Karplus
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
@GcL Yes. We want to know whether the spell duplicated by Wish has been cast. Twinned Spell only applies to spells that have been cast. Twinned Spell does apply, according to Sage Advice. Therefore, the duplicated spell has been cast.
$endgroup$
– Abe Karplus
5 hours ago












$begingroup$
excellent. Now I follow.
$endgroup$
– GcL
5 hours ago




$begingroup$
excellent. Now I follow.
$endgroup$
– GcL
5 hours ago













6












$begingroup$

A lot of weird things happen if a Duplicated Spell is not 'Cast'



In this post, I am not necessarily going to be making an argument as to whether a spell cast by Wish counts as being 'Cast' or not (well, maybe at the end...). I am, however, going to make arguments about what the consequences would be if using Wish to duplicate a spell means the spell in question has not been 'Cast'.



All of the following sections involve considerations that become true if a spell duplicated by Wish is not, mechanically, 'Casted'.



"When this spell is cast again..."



As mentioned in the linked question about Simulacrum, any spell that has a clause reading something like "if this spell is cast again..." would not have that clause take place. Simulacrums will stick around, you can summon multiple Spiritual Weapons, and so on.



"If you cast this spell with a higher spell slot..."



Any spell duplicated by Wish would be cast at its lowest level, and receive no benefits from being up-cast at a higher level of spell slot.



"As part of the action used to cast this spell..."



If the spell says that something does happens "as part of the casting of the spell", then that something doesn't happen.



This means that spells like Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade have no effect: they both stipulate that something occurs during the casting of the spell:




As part of the action used to cast this spell, you must make a melee attack with a weapon against one creature within the spell's range, otherwise the spell fails. [...]



Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade, Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide, pg. 142 & 143




This also affects spells like Teleportation Circle ("As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...") or Magic Circle ("When you cast this spell, you can elect to cause its magic to operate in the reverse direction...").



Esoteric: can a spell's casting be "wasted" if it was never cast?




You and up to eight willing creatures within range project your astral bodies into the Astral Plane (the spell fails and the casting is wasted if you are already on that plane).



Astral Projection, Player's Handbook, pg. 215




This is where the RAW becomes unclear: what happens if a spell fails without having been 'Cast'? What does "the casting is wasted" mean for a spell that wasn't cast?



"The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine..."




The effects of different spells add together while the durations of those spells overlap. The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine, however. Instead, the most potent effect—such as the highest bonus—from those castings applies while their durations overlap, or the most recent effect applies if the castings are equally potent and their durations overlap.



Combining Magical Effects, Player's Handbook, pg. 205




If the second spell produced by Wish was not 'Cast' into being, then this rule would not apply. After all, the rule specifically says that the spell has to be 'Cast' multiple times, and this would be the case from nearly any other source, including an Innate Spellcaster, but not from spells duplicated by Wish.



You can't Target yourself with an AOE spell




If a spell targets a creature of your choice, you can choose yourself, unless the creature must be hostile or specifically a creature other than you. If you are in the area of effect of a spell you cast, you can target yourself.



Targeting yourself, Player's Handbook, pg. 204




So if you're duplicating a spell that normally allows you to choose targets in an area of effect, you'd no longer be able to target yourself.




Let's try another angle...



From all that I've listed above, it's clear that the mechanical consequences of spells duplicated by Wish, if they don't count as being 'Cast', are quite significant. But the rules being weird is not sufficient proof that they're wrong or misinterpreted.



What does the chapter's opening paragraph say about Spellcasting?




Spellcasting



Magic permeates the worlds of D&D and most often appears in the form of a spell.



This chapter provides the rules for casting spells. Different character classes have distinctive ways of learning and preparing their spells, and monsters use spells in unique ways. Regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here.



Spellcasting, Player's Handbook, pg. 201




So here's an interesting passage: in the same paragraph, the book says both "this chapter provides the rules for casting spells", but also says "regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here".



There's [at least] two ways to interpret that.



One way is to say that that last sentence is an exception to the former: the chapter contains rules for casting spells, but spells produced by "some other means" still also obey those rules.



The other way is to say that the last sentence is implying that any spell produced by any source is obeying the same rules here because, implicitly, a spell produced by any other means has been 'Cast'.



So in one way, it might come down to how you interpret this paragraph. Under the latter interpretation, then yes, a spell duplicated by Wish was 'Cast'. There wouldn't be any way to resolve its effects otherwise.



Under the former interpretation... Well, unless someone finds the smoking gun I missed, then it comes down to what your DM says.






share|improve this answer











$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    If feasible, please put a tl;dr summation at the top of the post.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    3 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I think the argument is whether Wish duplicating a spell effect counts as casting the duplicated spell or counts as casting a Wish spell. How many sorcery points to quicken a Wish spell duplicating another spell? 9 or less than 9?
    $endgroup$
    – Quigath
    2 hours ago
















6












$begingroup$

A lot of weird things happen if a Duplicated Spell is not 'Cast'



In this post, I am not necessarily going to be making an argument as to whether a spell cast by Wish counts as being 'Cast' or not (well, maybe at the end...). I am, however, going to make arguments about what the consequences would be if using Wish to duplicate a spell means the spell in question has not been 'Cast'.



All of the following sections involve considerations that become true if a spell duplicated by Wish is not, mechanically, 'Casted'.



"When this spell is cast again..."



As mentioned in the linked question about Simulacrum, any spell that has a clause reading something like "if this spell is cast again..." would not have that clause take place. Simulacrums will stick around, you can summon multiple Spiritual Weapons, and so on.



"If you cast this spell with a higher spell slot..."



Any spell duplicated by Wish would be cast at its lowest level, and receive no benefits from being up-cast at a higher level of spell slot.



"As part of the action used to cast this spell..."



If the spell says that something does happens "as part of the casting of the spell", then that something doesn't happen.



This means that spells like Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade have no effect: they both stipulate that something occurs during the casting of the spell:




As part of the action used to cast this spell, you must make a melee attack with a weapon against one creature within the spell's range, otherwise the spell fails. [...]



Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade, Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide, pg. 142 & 143




This also affects spells like Teleportation Circle ("As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...") or Magic Circle ("When you cast this spell, you can elect to cause its magic to operate in the reverse direction...").



Esoteric: can a spell's casting be "wasted" if it was never cast?




You and up to eight willing creatures within range project your astral bodies into the Astral Plane (the spell fails and the casting is wasted if you are already on that plane).



Astral Projection, Player's Handbook, pg. 215




This is where the RAW becomes unclear: what happens if a spell fails without having been 'Cast'? What does "the casting is wasted" mean for a spell that wasn't cast?



"The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine..."




The effects of different spells add together while the durations of those spells overlap. The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine, however. Instead, the most potent effect—such as the highest bonus—from those castings applies while their durations overlap, or the most recent effect applies if the castings are equally potent and their durations overlap.



Combining Magical Effects, Player's Handbook, pg. 205




If the second spell produced by Wish was not 'Cast' into being, then this rule would not apply. After all, the rule specifically says that the spell has to be 'Cast' multiple times, and this would be the case from nearly any other source, including an Innate Spellcaster, but not from spells duplicated by Wish.



You can't Target yourself with an AOE spell




If a spell targets a creature of your choice, you can choose yourself, unless the creature must be hostile or specifically a creature other than you. If you are in the area of effect of a spell you cast, you can target yourself.



Targeting yourself, Player's Handbook, pg. 204




So if you're duplicating a spell that normally allows you to choose targets in an area of effect, you'd no longer be able to target yourself.




Let's try another angle...



From all that I've listed above, it's clear that the mechanical consequences of spells duplicated by Wish, if they don't count as being 'Cast', are quite significant. But the rules being weird is not sufficient proof that they're wrong or misinterpreted.



What does the chapter's opening paragraph say about Spellcasting?




Spellcasting



Magic permeates the worlds of D&D and most often appears in the form of a spell.



This chapter provides the rules for casting spells. Different character classes have distinctive ways of learning and preparing their spells, and monsters use spells in unique ways. Regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here.



Spellcasting, Player's Handbook, pg. 201




So here's an interesting passage: in the same paragraph, the book says both "this chapter provides the rules for casting spells", but also says "regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here".



There's [at least] two ways to interpret that.



One way is to say that that last sentence is an exception to the former: the chapter contains rules for casting spells, but spells produced by "some other means" still also obey those rules.



The other way is to say that the last sentence is implying that any spell produced by any source is obeying the same rules here because, implicitly, a spell produced by any other means has been 'Cast'.



So in one way, it might come down to how you interpret this paragraph. Under the latter interpretation, then yes, a spell duplicated by Wish was 'Cast'. There wouldn't be any way to resolve its effects otherwise.



Under the former interpretation... Well, unless someone finds the smoking gun I missed, then it comes down to what your DM says.






share|improve this answer











$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    If feasible, please put a tl;dr summation at the top of the post.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    3 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I think the argument is whether Wish duplicating a spell effect counts as casting the duplicated spell or counts as casting a Wish spell. How many sorcery points to quicken a Wish spell duplicating another spell? 9 or less than 9?
    $endgroup$
    – Quigath
    2 hours ago














6












6








6





$begingroup$

A lot of weird things happen if a Duplicated Spell is not 'Cast'



In this post, I am not necessarily going to be making an argument as to whether a spell cast by Wish counts as being 'Cast' or not (well, maybe at the end...). I am, however, going to make arguments about what the consequences would be if using Wish to duplicate a spell means the spell in question has not been 'Cast'.



All of the following sections involve considerations that become true if a spell duplicated by Wish is not, mechanically, 'Casted'.



"When this spell is cast again..."



As mentioned in the linked question about Simulacrum, any spell that has a clause reading something like "if this spell is cast again..." would not have that clause take place. Simulacrums will stick around, you can summon multiple Spiritual Weapons, and so on.



"If you cast this spell with a higher spell slot..."



Any spell duplicated by Wish would be cast at its lowest level, and receive no benefits from being up-cast at a higher level of spell slot.



"As part of the action used to cast this spell..."



If the spell says that something does happens "as part of the casting of the spell", then that something doesn't happen.



This means that spells like Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade have no effect: they both stipulate that something occurs during the casting of the spell:




As part of the action used to cast this spell, you must make a melee attack with a weapon against one creature within the spell's range, otherwise the spell fails. [...]



Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade, Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide, pg. 142 & 143




This also affects spells like Teleportation Circle ("As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...") or Magic Circle ("When you cast this spell, you can elect to cause its magic to operate in the reverse direction...").



Esoteric: can a spell's casting be "wasted" if it was never cast?




You and up to eight willing creatures within range project your astral bodies into the Astral Plane (the spell fails and the casting is wasted if you are already on that plane).



Astral Projection, Player's Handbook, pg. 215




This is where the RAW becomes unclear: what happens if a spell fails without having been 'Cast'? What does "the casting is wasted" mean for a spell that wasn't cast?



"The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine..."




The effects of different spells add together while the durations of those spells overlap. The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine, however. Instead, the most potent effect—such as the highest bonus—from those castings applies while their durations overlap, or the most recent effect applies if the castings are equally potent and their durations overlap.



Combining Magical Effects, Player's Handbook, pg. 205




If the second spell produced by Wish was not 'Cast' into being, then this rule would not apply. After all, the rule specifically says that the spell has to be 'Cast' multiple times, and this would be the case from nearly any other source, including an Innate Spellcaster, but not from spells duplicated by Wish.



You can't Target yourself with an AOE spell




If a spell targets a creature of your choice, you can choose yourself, unless the creature must be hostile or specifically a creature other than you. If you are in the area of effect of a spell you cast, you can target yourself.



Targeting yourself, Player's Handbook, pg. 204




So if you're duplicating a spell that normally allows you to choose targets in an area of effect, you'd no longer be able to target yourself.




Let's try another angle...



From all that I've listed above, it's clear that the mechanical consequences of spells duplicated by Wish, if they don't count as being 'Cast', are quite significant. But the rules being weird is not sufficient proof that they're wrong or misinterpreted.



What does the chapter's opening paragraph say about Spellcasting?




Spellcasting



Magic permeates the worlds of D&D and most often appears in the form of a spell.



This chapter provides the rules for casting spells. Different character classes have distinctive ways of learning and preparing their spells, and monsters use spells in unique ways. Regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here.



Spellcasting, Player's Handbook, pg. 201




So here's an interesting passage: in the same paragraph, the book says both "this chapter provides the rules for casting spells", but also says "regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here".



There's [at least] two ways to interpret that.



One way is to say that that last sentence is an exception to the former: the chapter contains rules for casting spells, but spells produced by "some other means" still also obey those rules.



The other way is to say that the last sentence is implying that any spell produced by any source is obeying the same rules here because, implicitly, a spell produced by any other means has been 'Cast'.



So in one way, it might come down to how you interpret this paragraph. Under the latter interpretation, then yes, a spell duplicated by Wish was 'Cast'. There wouldn't be any way to resolve its effects otherwise.



Under the former interpretation... Well, unless someone finds the smoking gun I missed, then it comes down to what your DM says.






share|improve this answer











$endgroup$



A lot of weird things happen if a Duplicated Spell is not 'Cast'



In this post, I am not necessarily going to be making an argument as to whether a spell cast by Wish counts as being 'Cast' or not (well, maybe at the end...). I am, however, going to make arguments about what the consequences would be if using Wish to duplicate a spell means the spell in question has not been 'Cast'.



All of the following sections involve considerations that become true if a spell duplicated by Wish is not, mechanically, 'Casted'.



"When this spell is cast again..."



As mentioned in the linked question about Simulacrum, any spell that has a clause reading something like "if this spell is cast again..." would not have that clause take place. Simulacrums will stick around, you can summon multiple Spiritual Weapons, and so on.



"If you cast this spell with a higher spell slot..."



Any spell duplicated by Wish would be cast at its lowest level, and receive no benefits from being up-cast at a higher level of spell slot.



"As part of the action used to cast this spell..."



If the spell says that something does happens "as part of the casting of the spell", then that something doesn't happen.



This means that spells like Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade have no effect: they both stipulate that something occurs during the casting of the spell:




As part of the action used to cast this spell, you must make a melee attack with a weapon against one creature within the spell's range, otherwise the spell fails. [...]



Booming Blade and Green Flame Blade, Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide, pg. 142 & 143




This also affects spells like Teleportation Circle ("As you cast the spell, you draw a 10-foot-diameter circle on the ground ...") or Magic Circle ("When you cast this spell, you can elect to cause its magic to operate in the reverse direction...").



Esoteric: can a spell's casting be "wasted" if it was never cast?




You and up to eight willing creatures within range project your astral bodies into the Astral Plane (the spell fails and the casting is wasted if you are already on that plane).



Astral Projection, Player's Handbook, pg. 215




This is where the RAW becomes unclear: what happens if a spell fails without having been 'Cast'? What does "the casting is wasted" mean for a spell that wasn't cast?



"The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine..."




The effects of different spells add together while the durations of those spells overlap. The effects of the same spell cast multiple times don't combine, however. Instead, the most potent effect—such as the highest bonus—from those castings applies while their durations overlap, or the most recent effect applies if the castings are equally potent and their durations overlap.



Combining Magical Effects, Player's Handbook, pg. 205




If the second spell produced by Wish was not 'Cast' into being, then this rule would not apply. After all, the rule specifically says that the spell has to be 'Cast' multiple times, and this would be the case from nearly any other source, including an Innate Spellcaster, but not from spells duplicated by Wish.



You can't Target yourself with an AOE spell




If a spell targets a creature of your choice, you can choose yourself, unless the creature must be hostile or specifically a creature other than you. If you are in the area of effect of a spell you cast, you can target yourself.



Targeting yourself, Player's Handbook, pg. 204




So if you're duplicating a spell that normally allows you to choose targets in an area of effect, you'd no longer be able to target yourself.




Let's try another angle...



From all that I've listed above, it's clear that the mechanical consequences of spells duplicated by Wish, if they don't count as being 'Cast', are quite significant. But the rules being weird is not sufficient proof that they're wrong or misinterpreted.



What does the chapter's opening paragraph say about Spellcasting?




Spellcasting



Magic permeates the worlds of D&D and most often appears in the form of a spell.



This chapter provides the rules for casting spells. Different character classes have distinctive ways of learning and preparing their spells, and monsters use spells in unique ways. Regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here.



Spellcasting, Player's Handbook, pg. 201




So here's an interesting passage: in the same paragraph, the book says both "this chapter provides the rules for casting spells", but also says "regardless of its source, a spell follows the rules here".



There's [at least] two ways to interpret that.



One way is to say that that last sentence is an exception to the former: the chapter contains rules for casting spells, but spells produced by "some other means" still also obey those rules.



The other way is to say that the last sentence is implying that any spell produced by any source is obeying the same rules here because, implicitly, a spell produced by any other means has been 'Cast'.



So in one way, it might come down to how you interpret this paragraph. Under the latter interpretation, then yes, a spell duplicated by Wish was 'Cast'. There wouldn't be any way to resolve its effects otherwise.



Under the former interpretation... Well, unless someone finds the smoking gun I missed, then it comes down to what your DM says.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited 3 hours ago









Rubiksmoose

61.1k10294450




61.1k10294450










answered 4 hours ago









XiremaXirema

23.6k268136




23.6k268136











  • $begingroup$
    If feasible, please put a tl;dr summation at the top of the post.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    3 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I think the argument is whether Wish duplicating a spell effect counts as casting the duplicated spell or counts as casting a Wish spell. How many sorcery points to quicken a Wish spell duplicating another spell? 9 or less than 9?
    $endgroup$
    – Quigath
    2 hours ago

















  • $begingroup$
    If feasible, please put a tl;dr summation at the top of the post.
    $endgroup$
    – GcL
    3 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    I think the argument is whether Wish duplicating a spell effect counts as casting the duplicated spell or counts as casting a Wish spell. How many sorcery points to quicken a Wish spell duplicating another spell? 9 or less than 9?
    $endgroup$
    – Quigath
    2 hours ago
















$begingroup$
If feasible, please put a tl;dr summation at the top of the post.
$endgroup$
– GcL
3 hours ago




$begingroup$
If feasible, please put a tl;dr summation at the top of the post.
$endgroup$
– GcL
3 hours ago












$begingroup$
I think the argument is whether Wish duplicating a spell effect counts as casting the duplicated spell or counts as casting a Wish spell. How many sorcery points to quicken a Wish spell duplicating another spell? 9 or less than 9?
$endgroup$
– Quigath
2 hours ago





$begingroup$
I think the argument is whether Wish duplicating a spell effect counts as casting the duplicated spell or counts as casting a Wish spell. How many sorcery points to quicken a Wish spell duplicating another spell? 9 or less than 9?
$endgroup$
– Quigath
2 hours ago


















draft saved

draft discarded
















































Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!


  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid


  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f144884%2fdoes-duplicating-a-spell-with-wish-count-as-casting-that-spell%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

Möglingen Índice Localización Historia Demografía Referencias Enlaces externos Menú de navegación48°53′18″N 9°07′45″E / 48.888333333333, 9.129166666666748°53′18″N 9°07′45″E / 48.888333333333, 9.1291666666667Sitio web oficial Mapa de Möglingen«Gemeinden in Deutschland nach Fläche, Bevölkerung und Postleitzahl am 30.09.2016»Möglingen

Virtualbox - Configuration error: Querying “UUID” failed (VERR_CFGM_VALUE_NOT_FOUND)“VERR_SUPLIB_WORLD_WRITABLE” error when trying to installing OS in virtualboxVirtual Box Kernel errorFailed to open a seesion for the virtual machineFailed to open a session for the virtual machineUbuntu 14.04 LTS Virtualbox errorcan't use VM VirtualBoxusing virtualboxI can't run Linux-64 Bit on VirtualBoxUnable to insert the virtual optical disk (VBoxguestaddition) in virtual machine for ubuntu server in win 10VirtuaBox in Ubuntu 18.04 Issues with Win10.ISO Installation

Torre de la Isleta Índice Véase también Referencias Bibliografía Enlaces externos Menú de navegación38°25′58″N 0°23′02″O / 38.43277778, -0.3838888938°25′58″N 0°23′02″O / 38.43277778, -0.38388889Torre de la Illeta de l’Horta o Torre Saleta. Base de datos de bienes inmuebles. Patrimonio Cultural. Secretaría de Estado de CulturaFicha BIC Torre de la Illeta de l’Horta. Dirección General de Patrimonio Cultural. Generalitat ValencianaLugares de interés. Ayuntamiento del CampelloTorre de la Isleta en CastillosNet.org